Government Interventions in Labour Disputes Have Unforeseen Costs: C.D. Howe Institute

Jun 17, 2010 | Government News

When politicians consider intervening in labour disputes, they should also consider the long-term, potentially unintended results of such action, according to a study released today by the C.D. Howe Institute.   In “The Laws of Unintended Consequence: The Effect of Labour Legislation on Wages and Strikes,” authors Benjamin Dachis and Robert Hebdon investigate the lessons from previous government legislative interventions, whether through compulsory arbitration, “back-to-work” legislation or bans on replacement workers during strikes, and find these actions have unintended results that give reason for sober second thought. 

Among their findings: 

– Banning strikes increases public-sector wage levels appreciably. Legislation requiring compulsory arbitration in disputes involving public employees has increased wages by about 1.2 percent per settlement.

– “Back-to-work” legislation reduces the likelihood of a freely settled contract in the next round of negotiations, perpetuating the cycle of government intervention.

– Bans on temporary replacement workers reduce wages, contrary to previous evidence, and increase the likelihood and length of strikes, as do reinstatement rights for striking workers.

– Allowing union certification only through a secret ballot decreases the number of strikes and lowers the wage costs of unionized employees.

This Commentary provides policymakers with a fresh perspective on their potential actions and consequences in the minefield of labour disputes. Whether governments seek to shift the balance of labour-employer power, end work stoppages or prevent them in the first place, policymakers should weigh the unintended consequences before acting. 

For the study go to: 

For more information contact:           

Ben Dachis, Policy Analyst, C.D. Howe Institute; or Robert Hebdon, Professor, McGill University.  Phone 416-865-1904 email: [email protected].

Similar Posts


advertisement advertisement


This year’s #MBBizOutlookSurvey features questions in eight categories, including economic competitiveness, business performance, and labour force, with targeted questions on the impact of inflation and the importance of trade.

We want to hear from you:

This year, CME Manitoba is offering 𝗧𝗛𝗥𝗘𝗘 𝗦𝗖𝗛𝗢𝗟𝗔𝗥𝗦𝗛𝗜𝗣𝗦 to students pursuing a potential career in manufacturing.

Do you have a university student at home? Applications accepted until 𝗝𝗮𝗻𝘂𝗮𝗿𝘆 𝟭𝟱, 𝟮𝟬𝟮𝟯!